Home
Blog
Overview of all products
SalesData
LibraryData
CataList
Loan Stars
BiblioShare
Webform
EDI
Products for publishers
Products for retailers
Products for libraries
Information for authors
BNC Research
Canadian literary awards
SalesData & LibraryData Research Portal
Events
Tech Forum
Webinars & Training
Code of Conduct
Standards
EDI standards
Product identifiers
Classification schemes
ONIX standards
About
Contact us
Media
Bestseller lists
Newsletters
Podcast
Jobs
SalesData
LibraryData
CataList
BiblioShare
Webform
EDI

BookNet Canada

Home
Blog
Overview of all products
SalesData
LibraryData
CataList
Loan Stars
BiblioShare
Webform
EDI
Products for publishers
Products for retailers
Products for libraries
Information for authors
BNC Research
Canadian literary awards
SalesData & LibraryData Research Portal
Events
Tech Forum
Webinars & Training
Code of Conduct
Standards
EDI standards
Product identifiers
Classification schemes
ONIX standards
About
Contact us
Media
Bestseller lists
Newsletters
Podcast
Jobs
SalesData
LibraryData
CataList
BiblioShare
Webform
EDI
Lauren Stewart
January 17, 2023
Standards & Metadata, Thema

The importance of clearly indicating a main subject when using Thema and other subject classification schemes

Lauren Stewart
January 17, 2023
Standards & Metadata, Thema
Learn about the importance of clearly indicating a main subject when using Thema and other subject classification schemes.
CLICK TO TWEET

When creating metadata records, it’s very tempting to include every subject code that has the potential to identify the product to even the most niche audiences to increase readership — and purchases! Think of the possibilities, right? No audience left untouched. However, in the rush to assign subjects, as we've noted in the past, even the most skilled data provider can make an all-too-common mistake: including a variety of subjects but neglecting to indicate one as the main subject.

When providing more than one subject code from Thema for a product, it's vital to include an indication of which of the several codes is the most important one. This applies to any subject scheme listed in ONIX codelist 27 that allows multiple codes from that scheme.

You’ve heard appeals from us before where subject classifications and main subjects are concerned. As Tom Richardson wrote back in February 2021:

Subject classification uses standard definitions to describe the content of something. A book subject classification system — like Thema, BISAC, Dewey, or Library of Congress (LOC) — starts with some preconceived ordering of a worldview [sic] that is done with a purpose. Dewey and LOC are library systems to classify knowledge. Thema and BISAC exist to classify book content to facilitate consumer discoverability and ensure usability by book retailers. All are tools for content discovery with different focuses.

A “main subject” doesn’t exist in library subjects systems. And a good generalization about any subject scheme is: either a subject applies and it should be used, or it doesn’t and it shouldn’t be used. That means that subjects don’t usually have a hierarchy — the book content should relate to a search based on any of the subject terms provided.

Trade book subject classifications like Thema and BISAC (BIC has been superseded by Thema, but it belongs in this list, too) support main subjects for the convenience of their retail partners. Knowing what the book is ‘mostly’ about can help sales in a number of ways, but this is the important one in North America:

A retail book buyer is normally a subject specialist and the single “main subject” defines which buyer receives the sales pitch. In other words: the main subject is a focal point for your sales effort.

A year later, sadly, the issue is still popping up, even in files sent from the most skilled data providers.

BookNet has heard rumours that some software vendors may think the order in the record, with the first entry as “main,” is sufficient. It is not! Accuracy demands that you positively label one of the subjects as main. Are you even sure your software allows you to change the order of entries?

To answer the call, standards lead EDItEUR has crafted an essential document for data providers to consider when creating and sending subject classifications in their ONIX records. Here are the most salient points:

  1. Indicate the main subject using the <MainSubject/> tag in ONIX 3.0. Publishers still using ONIX 2.1 should use the <MainSubject> composite.

  2. The <MainSubject/> is expected to be a permanent assignment, not a code that will change frequently during the product’s lifecycle. While corrections can be made to a book’s subject classification after initially assigned, publishers are urged to exercise restraint with the <MainSubject/> as frequent changes suggest a lack of stability and reduce the usefulness of subject categorization to data recipients. The document asserts “it is better to take time prior to publication to decide the best category to be the main one and which other subjects and qualifiers make sense with this main subject.”

  3. When double-coding Fiction and Non-Fiction categories using the Thema subject standard (BISAC discourages double-coding Fiction and Non-Fiction codes), for example when using a Non-Fiction code to describe the setting for the fictional story, about the setting or milieu of a story, the Fiction code must be indicated as the <MainSubject/>. This decisively informs data recipients that the book “is a work of fiction title rather than a work of non-fiction.”

As short and simple as these directives suggest, the document elaborates with examples to illustrate the complicated decision-making that one must associate with subject coding. An essential read, presented here for your consideration.

Got questions for us? Drop us a line, we’re always happy to talk Standards!

Subscribe

Don’t miss any new blog posts. Sign up for our weekly eNews to receive updates.

You can unsubscribe at any time. We respect your privacy.

Thank you!
Recent posts
Common metadata issues and how to fix them: Display issues caused by rogue &lt;div&gt; tags
Common metadata issues and how to fix them: Display issues caused by rogue <div> tags

Tips on how to avoid display issues caused by rogue <div> tags.

Read More →
5 questions with Terrier Books
5 questions with Terrier Books

5 questions with Gladys VALLEE-AGRICOLE, the owner of Terrier Books.

Read More →
Buy Canadian: What it means for the book market
Buy Canadian: What it means for the book market

What can the Canadian book market do to support the Buy Canadian movement?

Read More →
EU Deforestation Regulation and ONIX: Advice worth reading from EDItEUR
EU Deforestation Regulation and ONIX: Advice worth reading from EDItEUR

EDItEUR’s new Application Note.

Read More →
ONIX Codelist 70 released
ONIX Codelist 70 released

Insights into the latest updates and additions made to ONIX codelists.

Read More →
Subjects on the move in the Canadian market
Subjects on the move in the Canadian market

Subject trend sales from January 2025 to June 2025.

Read More →
Subject spotlight: Cooking
Subject spotlight: Cooking

Sales and library circulation data of Cooking titles during the the second quarter of 2025.

Read More →
Most circulated Canadian books: July 2024 to July 2025
Most circulated Canadian books: July 2024 to July 2025

The most circulated Canadian books from July 1, 2024, to July 6, 2025.

Read More →
Making the bestseller list: The true impact of a pre-order campaign
Making the bestseller list: The true impact of a pre-order campaign

We had a chat with Kim Werker, Co-Founder and Publisher of Nine Ten Publications about their recent bestseller.

Read More →
The Booksellers' List
The Booksellers' List

The Booksellers’ List is here!

Read More →
Bestselling Canadian books: July 2024 to July 2025
Bestselling Canadian books: July 2024 to July 2025

The bestselling Canadian books from July 1, 2024, to July 6, 2025.

Read More →
5 questions with Roots &amp; Bridge
5 questions with Roots & Bridge

5 questions with Brian Li, the President of Roots & Bridge.

Read More →

Tagged: book metadata best practices

Newer PostTech Forum: Most viewed videos of 2022
Older PostSubject spotlight: Business & Economics
Blog RSS

The Canadian Book Market 2024 is the comprehensive guide to the Canadian market with in-depth category data.

Get your copy now

Listen to our latest podcast episode


  • Research & Analysis 457
  • Ebooks 304
  • Tech Forum 269
  • Conferences & Events 261
  • Standards & Metadata 234
  • Bookselling 219
  • Publishing 195
  • ONIX 180
  • Marketing 152
  • Podcasts 119
  • ebookcraft 112
  • BookNet News 100
  • Loan Stars 72
  • Libraries 66
  • BiblioShare 59
  • 5 Questions With 50
  • SalesData 50
  • CataList 43
  • Thema 43
  • Awards 30
  • Diversity & Inclusion 21
  • Publishing & COVID-19 18
  • EU Regulations 11
  • Sustainability 11
  • LibraryData 10
  • ISNI 4

 

 

BookNet Canada is a non-profit organization that develops technology, standards, and education to serve the Canadian book industry. Founded in 2002 to address systemic challenges in the industry, BookNet Canada supports publishing companies, booksellers, wholesalers, distributors, sales agents, industry associations, literary agents, media, and libraries across the country.

 

Privacy Policy | Accessibility Policy | About Us

BOOKNET CANADA

Contact us | (416) 362-5057 or toll free 1 (877) 770-5261

We acknowledge the financial support of the Government of Canada through the Canada Book Fund (CBF) for this project.

Back to Top

BookNet Canada acknowledges that its operations are remote and our colleagues contribute their work from the traditional territories of the Mississaugas of the Credit First Nation, the Anishnawbe, the Haudenosaunee, the Wyandot, the Mi’kmaq, the Ojibwa of Fort William First Nation, the Three Fires Confederacy of First Nations (which includes the Ojibwa, the Odawa, and the Potawatomie), and the Métis, the original nations and peoples of the lands we now call Beeton, Brampton, Guelph, Halifax, Thunder Bay, Toronto, Vaughan, and Windsor. We endorse the Calls to Action from the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada (PDF) and support an ongoing shift from gatekeeping to spacemaking in the book industry.