Home
Blog
Overview of all products
SalesData
LibraryData
CataList
Loan Stars
BiblioShare
Webform
EDI
Products for publishers
Products for retailers
Products for libraries
Information for authors
BNC Research
Canadian literary awards
SalesData & LibraryData Research Portal
Events
Tech Forum
Webinars & Training
Code of Conduct
Standards
EDI standards
Product identifiers
Classification schemes
ONIX standards
About
Contact us
Media
Bestseller lists
Newsletters
Podcast
Jobs
SalesData
LibraryData
CataList
BiblioShare
Webform
EDI

BookNet Canada

Home
Blog
Overview of all products
SalesData
LibraryData
CataList
Loan Stars
BiblioShare
Webform
EDI
Products for publishers
Products for retailers
Products for libraries
Information for authors
BNC Research
Canadian literary awards
SalesData & LibraryData Research Portal
Events
Tech Forum
Webinars & Training
Code of Conduct
Standards
EDI standards
Product identifiers
Classification schemes
ONIX standards
About
Contact us
Media
Bestseller lists
Newsletters
Podcast
Jobs
SalesData
LibraryData
CataList
BiblioShare
Webform
EDI
Tom Richardson
April 20, 2010
BiblioShare, ONIX, Standards & Metadata

The BiblioShare Certification Challenge

Tom Richardson
April 20, 2010
BiblioShare, ONIX, Standards & Metadata

BNC BiblioShare is going gangbusters with over 230,000 EANs in the system, over 12,000 Canadian author markers and aggregators starting to experiment with the data. It seems like a good time to take stock.

One of the first things we found is anyone who wants the data really wants—and I mean really really wants—Canadian indicators, as much as they can get. I’m required at every opportunity to list these, so to review:

  • Canadian authorship is shown using the Contributor composite’s country code;
  • BISAC Regional Codes (code 11 in the Subject composite) can be used to draw the attention of a region’s book buyers or libraries;
  • if you’re still using an old BISAC code list, well, you know: a number of Canada specific codes were added 3 or 4 years ago and you should update yearly.

The industry wants to promote your books, so help them. There’s even been some feelers about, maybe, getting publishers to use Country of Publication more too—and Country of Manufacture can be in the mix too and with Code Issue 11 you can include it in ONIX 2.1 files using the familiar Other Text composite.

The other piece of feedback that we’re getting from aggregators is: Why is the data so inconsistent (actual adjectives have been standardized in the interest of simplicity and taste)? Even BookNet Canada’s own programmer has wondered, the programmer from the ACP’s Bookshelf (as experienced an ONIX producer as exists in Canada) has been caustic, and Library and Archives Canada has been close to un-librarian-like.

This is not a problem unique to Canada: BIC’s most recent annual report said the same thing and questioned the effectiveness of certifying publishers, it was discussed last year at the ONIX meetings at the London Book Fair and if not for volcanoes would have been again.

When it gets to e-pub metadata the universally agreed descriptor is crap.

It’s a feature of BNC BiblioShare that it’s the publisher’s data and that rather than changing it we work with publishers to make it better.

Just to be clear, BNC’s aggregated dataset—the stuff we’ll be serving up over the web and issuing as aggregated files from our own database—will have some level of standardization in it, but we aren’t staffed or funded to do a intensive remediation of files. Actually, that how the industry got to where it is. Big Publishers submitted files and Big Retail’s programmers wrote scripts, publisher by publisher, to clean them up to match as best it could their individual standard. Bowker and other aggregators invested heavily in systems to compensate so that their output is a clean as they can make it. And it’s lovely! But the smaller the publisher the less economic that model is, and everyone who’s data has been changed knows it’s a mixed blessing: the fix can be its own problem.

So, I say again: It’s a feature of BNC BiblioShare that it’s the publisher’s data. The size of file is irrelevant to us because all files are processed the same—the only limit to getting in is they have to pass a strict validation. But once that’s passed we work with publishers to make it better. Each and every file has its own Detailed Report—it’s not perfect or the final word on data quality but it’s very good. Mind you it’s only good if publisher’s use it and think that these are things they should fix.

And this leads to a question for the Canadian publishing industry: What do you want from certification? The aggregators we’re working with seem to think that a publisher file that’s been “certified” should be usable without work on their part. And by that they mean: quality bibliographic information that really matches the book, full utilization of all the correct ONIX elements, no glitchy characters, Canadian identifiers up the wazoo, as much enhanced content a possible… They’re pretty demanding given they are trying to provide publishers with free discover-ability and support.

This seems like a no-brainer—of course a certified file should be usable! But I’m not sure. Does Canada want a hard-assed data certification system? What are the boundaries of failure to certify? What should that mean?

Here’s a chance to talk about it and comment below…

Tagged: epub

Newer PostFacebook's Open Graph Has Huge Potential for Books
Older PostThis Week's BNC Tech Forum 2010 Video: Michael Tamblyn
Blog RSS

The Canadian Book Market 2024 is the comprehensive guide to the Canadian market with in-depth category data.

Get your copy now

Listen to our latest podcast episode


  • Research & Analysis 447
  • Ebooks 304
  • Tech Forum 266
  • Conferences & Events 261
  • Standards & Metadata 228
  • Bookselling 218
  • Publishing 194
  • ONIX 178
  • Marketing 152
  • Podcasts 118
  • ebookcraft 112
  • BookNet News 99
  • Loan Stars 71
  • Libraries 66
  • BiblioShare 59
  • SalesData 51
  • 5 Questions With 48
  • CataList 42
  • Thema 42
  • Awards 30
  • Diversity & Inclusion 21
  • Publishing & COVID-19 18
  • Sustainability 10
  • LibraryData 9
  • EU Regulations 8
  • ISNI 4

 

 

BookNet Canada is a non-profit organization that develops technology, standards, and education to serve the Canadian book industry. Founded in 2002 to address systemic challenges in the industry, BookNet Canada supports publishing companies, booksellers, wholesalers, distributors, sales agents, industry associations, literary agents, media, and libraries across the country.

 

Privacy Policy | Accessibility Policy | About Us

BOOKNET CANADA

Contact us | (416) 362-5057 or toll free 1 (877) 770-5261

We acknowledge the financial support of the Government of Canada through the Canada Book Fund (CBF) for this project.

Back to Top

BookNet Canada acknowledges that its operations are remote and our colleagues contribute their work from the traditional territories of the Mississaugas of the Credit First Nation, the Anishnawbe, the Haudenosaunee, the Wyandot, the Mi’kmaq, the Ojibwa of Fort William First Nation, the Three Fires Confederacy of First Nations (which includes the Ojibwa, the Odawa, and the Potawatomie), and the Métis, the original nations and peoples of the lands we now call Beeton, Brampton, Guelph, Halifax, Thunder Bay, Toronto, Vaughan, and Windsor. We endorse the Calls to Action from the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada (PDF) and support an ongoing shift from gatekeeping to spacemaking in the book industry.